评估CPU内核的优化 - 页 7

新评论
 

因此，再次重新编译了所有三个EA。

英特尔酷睿i7-8700，3.2GHz，16Gb内存，6核心。

启用超线程。

六个代理，Tree_Brut_TestPL。

2019.08.13 16:19:02.912 Core 03 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.050
2019.08.13 16:19:02.943 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.127
2019.08.13 16:19:03.032 Core 02 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.166
2019.08.13 16:19:03.238 Core 06 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.372
2019.08.13 16:19:03.565 Core 04 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.703
2019.08.13 16:19:03.784 Core 11 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.947

十二个代理，Tree_Brut_TestPL。

2019.08.13 16:24:28.900 Core 12 pass 11 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:43.168
2019.08.13 16:24:29.595 Core 05 pass 10 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:43.898
2019.08.13 16:24:29.897 Core 03 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:44.675
2019.08.13 16:24:30.425 Core 10 pass 8 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:44.806
2019.08.13 16:24:30.488 Core 02 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:45.264
2019.08.13 16:24:30.635 Core 09 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:45.405
2019.08.13 16:24:30.720 Core 08 pass 7 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:45.122
2019.08.13 16:24:30.721 Core 06 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:45.497
2019.08.13 16:24:31.081 Core 07 pass 9 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:45.422
2019.08.13 16:24:31.882 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:46.660
2019.08.13 16:24:31.992 Core 11 pass 6 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:46.769
2019.08.13 16:24:32.075 Core 04 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:46.852
2019.08.13 16:24:32.075 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 12
2019.08.13 16:24:32.086 Statistics      optimization done in 1 minutes 47 seconds
2019.08.13 16:24:32.086 Statistics      shortest pass 0:01:43.168, longest pass 0:01:46.852, average pass 0:01:45.294

六个代理，Tree_Brut_TestPL_F。

2019.08.13 16:27:35.754 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:16.198
2019.08.13 16:27:35.969 Core 06 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:16.423
2019.08.13 16:27:36.112 Core 04 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:16.577
2019.08.13 16:27:36.246 Core 03 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:16.764
2019.08.13 16:27:36.374 Core 02 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:16.905
2019.08.13 16:27:37.184 Core 05 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:17.664
2019.08.13 16:27:37.184 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 6
2019.08.13 16:27:37.194 Statistics      optimization done in 1 minutes 19 seconds
2019.08.13 16:27:37.194 Statistics      shortest pass 0:01:16.198, longest pass 0:01:17.664, average pass 0:01:16.755

十二个代理，Tree_Brut_TestPL_F。

2019.08.13 16:36:28.083 Core 11 pass 7 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:18.279
2019.08.13 16:36:28.473 Core 05 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:18.672
2019.08.13 16:36:28.525 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:18.724
2019.08.13 16:36:29.260 Core 04 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:19.459
2019.08.13 16:36:30.106 Core 10 pass 10 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:20.305
2019.08.13 16:36:30.865 Core 08 pass 6 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:21.064
2019.08.13 16:36:31.414 Core 06 pass 8 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:21.613
2019.08.13 16:36:31.556 Core 12 pass 11 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:21.754
2019.08.13 16:36:31.894 Core 03 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:22.094
2019.08.13 16:36:33.473 Core 02 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:23.673
2019.08.13 16:36:35.412 Core 09 pass 9 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:25.612
2019.08.13 16:36:35.493 Core 07 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:03:25.693
2019.08.13 16:36:35.493 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 12
2019.08.13 16:36:35.503 Statistics      optimization done in 3 minutes 26 seconds
2019.08.13 16:36:35.503 Statistics      shortest pass 0:03:18.279, longest pass 0:03:25.693, average pass 0:03:21.411

六个代理人,Tree_Brut_TestPL_F_Fast。 

2019.08.13 16:39:28.522 Core 02 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:16.755
2019.08.13 16:39:28.549 Core 03 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:16.781
2019.08.13 16:39:29.010 Core 06 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:17.247
2019.08.13 16:39:29.085 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:17.375
2019.08.13 16:39:29.607 Core 04 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:17.821
2019.08.13 16:39:29.716 Core 05 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:17.996
2019.08.13 16:39:29.716 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 6
2019.08.13 16:39:29.726 Statistics      optimization done in 0 minutes 18 seconds
2019.08.13 16:39:29.726 Statistics      shortest pass 0:00:16.755, longest pass 0:00:17.996, average pass 0:00:17.329

12个代理商，Tree_Brut_TestPL_F_Fast。 

2019.08.13 16:41:11.638 Core 04 pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:29.382
2019.08.13 16:41:11.827 Core 06 pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:29.573
2019.08.13 16:41:12.313 Core 02 pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:30.060
2019.08.13 16:41:12.826 Core 07 pass 9 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:30.030
2019.08.13 16:41:12.907 Core 08 pass 6 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:30.115
2019.08.13 16:41:13.695 Core 01 pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:31.442
2019.08.13 16:41:13.927 Core 05 pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:31.673
2019.08.13 16:41:13.964 Core 09 pass 7 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:31.219
2019.08.13 16:41:15.006 Core 03 pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:32.752
2019.08.13 16:41:15.381 Core 10 pass 10 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:32.558
2019.08.13 16:41:16.244 Core 11 pass 8 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.420
2019.08.13 16:41:16.365 Core 12 pass 11 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:33.536
2019.08.13 16:41:16.365 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 12
2019.08.13 16:41:16.376 Statistics      optimization done in 0 minutes 34 seconds
2019.08.13 16:41:16.376 Statistics      shortest pass 0:00:29.382, longest pass 0:00:33.536, average pass 0:00:31.313

关掉超级交易。

六个代理人，Tree_Brut_TestPL。

2019.08.13 16:46:06.369 Core 5  pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:37.248
2019.08.13 16:46:06.958 Core 1  pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:37.861
2019.08.13 16:46:07.391 Core 6  pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:38.282
2019.08.13 16:46:07.722 Core 4  pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:38.611
2019.08.13 16:46:08.158 Core 3  pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:39.045
2019.08.13 16:46:08.305 Core 2  pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:39.164
2019.08.13 16:46:08.305 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 6
2019.08.13 16:46:08.316 Statistics      optimization done in 0 minutes 40 seconds
2019.08.13 16:46:08.316 Statistics      shortest pass 0:00:37.248, longest pass 0:00:39.164, average pass 0:00:38.368

六种药剂，Tree_Brut_TestPL_F。

2019.08.13 16:53:21.112 Core 6  pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:10.789
2019.08.13 16:53:21.517 Core 1  pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:11.240
2019.08.13 16:53:21.660 Core 2  pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:11.523
2019.08.13 16:53:21.993 Core 4  pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:11.648
2019.08.13 16:53:22.054 Core 5  pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:11.713
2019.08.13 16:53:22.951 Core 3  pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:12.710
2019.08.13 16:53:22.951 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 6
2019.08.13 16:53:22.961 Statistics      optimization done in 1 minutes 13 seconds
2019.08.13 16:53:22.961 Statistics      shortest pass 0:01:10.789, longest pass 0:01:12.710, average pass 0:01:11.603

六个代理人，Tree_Brut_TestPL_F_Fast。 

2019.08.13 16:54:51.756 Core 3  pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.678
2019.08.13 16:54:51.810 Core 4  pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.727
2019.08.13 16:54:51.842 Core 2  pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.765
2019.08.13 16:54:51.873 Core 5  pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.881
2019.08.13 16:54:51.939 Core 6  pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.856
2019.08.13 16:54:51.961 Core 1  pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:00:14.915
2019.08.13 16:54:51.961 Tester  optimization finished, total passes 6
2019.08.13 16:54:51.972 Statistics      optimization done in 0 minutes 15 seconds
2019.08.13 16:54:51.972 Statistics      shortest pass 0:00:14.678, longest pass 0:00:14.915, average pass 0:00:14.803
 
Aleksey Vyazmikin:

谢谢，但要加上Tree_Brut_TestPL_F和Tree_Brut_TestPL的评估结果 !

编译当然是长的）））我这才看到代码的数量。

树_Brut_TestPL

4个代理8个通过

Q       0       20:33:03.992    Core 3  pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:28.086
DF      0       20:33:06.162    Core 2  pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:30.305
DL      0       20:33:06.954    Core 1  pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:31.043
KE      0       20:33:06.998    Core 4  pass 6 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:31.025
EK      0       20:34:33.114    Core 3  pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:29.133
DP      0       20:34:36.197    Core 2  pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:30.045
GI      0       20:34:37.233    Core 4  pass 7 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:30.244
RO      0       20:34:37.410    Core 1  pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:01:30.465
KK      0       20:34:37.410    Tester  optimization finished, total passes 8
GO      0       20:34:37.420    Statistics      optimization done in 3 minutes 02 seconds
PF      0       20:34:37.420    Statistics      shortest pass 0:01:28.086, longest pass 0:01:31.043, average pass 0:01:30.043
CF      0       20:34:37.420    Statistics      8000 frames (3.14 Mb total, 412 bytes per frame) received
RE      0       20:34:37.421    Statistics      local 8 tasks (100%), remote 0 tasks (0%), cloud 0 tasks (0%)

8名特工，8张通行证

EE      0       20:40:18.642    Core 1  pass 0 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:08.677
JJ      0       20:40:18.846    Core 8  pass 7 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:08.405
GP      0       20:40:19.243    Core 6  pass 5 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:08.930
DI      0       20:40:19.870    Core 2  pass 1 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:09.912
OO      0       20:40:20.049    Core 4  pass 3 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:10.090
MD      0       20:40:20.307    Core 3  pass 2 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:10.350
FM      0       20:40:21.323    Core 7  pass 6 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:10.983
PS      0       20:40:21.375    Core 5  pass 4 returned result 1001000.00 in 0:02:11.110
KG      0       20:40:21.375    Tester  optimization finished, total passes 8
NS      0       20:40:21.386    Statistics      optimization done in 2 minutes 12 seconds
NJ      0       20:40:21.386    Statistics      shortest pass 0:02:08.405, longest pass 0:02:11.110, average pass 0:02:09.807
RJ      0       20:40:21.386    Statistics      8000 frames (3.14 Mb total, 412 bytes per frame) received
DQ      0       20:40:21.386    Statistics      local 8 tasks (100%), remote 0 tasks (0%), cloud 0 tasks (0%)

树_Brut_TestPL_F

4个代理8个通过

EI      0       20:47:44.732    Core 1  pass 0 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:43.903
MN      0       20:47:46.827    Core 4  pass 6 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:45.985
DG      0       20:47:49.535    Core 2  pass 2 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:48.698
GM      0       20:47:52.933    Core 3  pass 4 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:52.631
LR      0       20:50:13.736    Core 1  pass 1 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:29.026
EH      0       20:50:19.324    Core 4  pass 7 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:32.515
PQ      0       20:50:25.653    Core 2  pass 3 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:36.136
CF      0       20:50:32.200    Core 3  pass 5 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:02:39.285
ES      0       20:50:32.200    Tester  optimization finished, total passes 8
OG      0       20:50:32.211    Statistics      optimization done in 5 minutes 36 seconds
NN      0       20:50:32.211    Statistics      shortest pass 0:02:29.026, longest pass 0:02:52.631, average pass 0:02:41.022
LO      0       20:50:32.211    Statistics      8000 frames (3.14 Mb total, 412 bytes per frame) received
JJ      0       20:50:32.211    Statistics      local 8 tasks (100%), remote 0 tasks (0%), cloud 0 tasks (0%)

8家代理公司8次通过

KG      0       20:56:41.505    Core 3  pass 2 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:42.298
JL      0       20:56:42.220    Core 2  pass 1 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:43.017
IE      0       20:56:42.573    Core 1  pass 0 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:43.367
DK      0       20:56:43.809    Core 4  pass 3 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:44.609
DP      0       20:56:44.715    Core 7  pass 6 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:44.424
GF      0       20:56:45.115    Core 5  pass 4 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:44.974
IO      0       20:56:45.763    Core 6  pass 5 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:45.587
KD      0       20:56:46.010    Core 8  pass 7 returned result 1000000.00 in 0:03:45.727
GE      0       20:56:46.010    Tester  optimization finished, total passes 8
IQ      0       20:56:46.020    Statistics      optimization done in 3 minutes 48 seconds
JH      0       20:56:46.020    Statistics      shortest pass 0:03:42.298, longest pass 0:03:45.727, average pass 0:03:44.250
OM      0       20:56:46.020    Statistics      8000 frames (3.14 Mb total, 412 bytes per frame) received
FL      0       20:56:46.021    Statistics      local 8 tasks (100%), remote 0 tasks (0%), cloud 0 tasks (0%)

4家和8家代理商的速度相差27-32%。我认为问题出在内存缓存上，FX因其缓存瓶颈而臭名昭著。不幸的是，我无法超频来检查，我的石头完全没有内存和北桥超频。

 
但是，如果你比较f和f-fast版本，差异是巨大的！在这里，他们是6.79倍优化的奇迹。或者应该与哪个版本的f-fast进行比较？
 
Georgiy Merts:

于是，再次重新编译了所有三个EA。

数字下降了一些--暂时把它们带到了桌子上。计算机在优化过程中是否启用了自动增压功能？

 
Maxim Romanov:

4个和8个代理的速度差为27-32%。我认为问题出在内存缓存上，FX以其缓存瓶颈而闻名。不幸的是，我无法超频来检查，我的石头完全没有内存和北桥的超频。

我把它写成了4个FPU核心。

马克西姆-罗曼诺夫。
但是，如果你比较f和f-fast版本，差异是巨大的！这里他们是6.79优化的奇迹。或者你应该和哪个版本的f-fast进行比较？

我同意，它是惊人的。你正确地比较了这些版本。有趣的是，从i7-8700的差距来看，老式处理器的百分比已经缩小。

 

目前的数据--蓝色为无测试结果。

E5-2670 2片现在明显领先于i7-8700，这很有意义。

 
Aleksey Vyazmikin:

这些数字略有下降--暂时把它们收进一个表格。计算机在优化过程中是否启用了自动增压功能？

很有可能，是的。在BIOS中有很多微调参数，但我没有去研究，只是设置了性能配置文件。

 
Georgiy Merts:

很有可能，是的。在BIOS中有很多微调参数，但我没有进入这些参数，我只是设置了性能配置文件。

那么，也许当超级交易被关闭时，助推器会更快或以更高的频率激活。将客观测试的频率固定下来就好了。

 

我添加了E5-2470处理器的结果--2个单元，虽然那里的内存是DDR3-800，可能稍微低估了潜力，但我不认为明显--5%到10%。

我决定看看二手元件的价格，以评估组装的可行性--价格取自Avito和Aliexpress。

计算方法如下--装配成本（"总 "栏）除以每小时的通过次数。筛选是针对最后一列，但也是一列，因为专家顾问是最重的一列，而不是所有的专家顾问，不幸的是，他们都给出了最后一个EA的数据。


看来，即使考虑到二手市场的价格，i7-8700也是一个非常好的优化选择。

插座AM3和AM3+上的AMD处理器的内存被当作特殊的，只用于AMD（我自己使用）--频率1600。

DDR4内存频率2600 - 更高的频率与性能增益不相称，从其他来源的测试来看。

对于稍微强大的处理器可以节省冷却器 - 500卢布。

电源采取了500瓦 - 这真的足够了，如果不是假的或已经死了，但如果可能的话最好得到一个新的，但不是顶级的，但bu的价格是奠定了一个非常坚实的选择。

所有变体的显卡都集成在处理器或母体中，除了Ryzen，但在250-300卢布的插头决定不考虑作为一个例外。

 

看来这个话题要烂尾了，我把我用来统计的文件丢掉，用excel画表。

附加的文件：
CPU_Test_FX.zip  25 kb
1234567891011121314...22
新评论