Redrawing - good or bad. - page 2

 
I'm sorry, I'm speaking in the abstract because I have a negative opinion of PI.
Are you referring to https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/7375?
 
grell писал(а) >>
I apologise, I am reasoning in the abstract as I have formed a negative opinion of the PI.
Are you referring to https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/7375?

No - alas - it's a misnomer that TMA is triangular - I'm talking about the real one, the iML3.... https://c.mql5.com/mql4/forum/2010/04/experts.zip and the subject - https://forum.mql4.com/ru/17579 and its sequel https://forum.mql4.com/ru/31145
 
SProgrammer писал(а) >> Even more so, the very fact of redrawing MUST be seen as an important event. :)

What does this event mean?

 
LeoV писал(а) >>

What does this event mean?


It depends on the indicator, doesn't it?

 
SProgrammer писал(а) >> It depends on the indicator, doesn't it?


In a global sense, what does it mean? Not in a private sense.
 
Well, it's an event. That's something.
 
LeoV писал(а) >>


In the global sense, what does it mean? Not in a private sense.


Well that would be different - I have ( now ) no common answers. But in general - the idea is interesting.
***
For iML3 ( TMA ), it means that OY is better to stay away from the market. Like a signal - "out of the market", for one strategy, for the other - on the contrary. :)
 
All indicators based on averages will suffer from "overshoot"
alas

--
but indicators based on levels do not suffer from this problem
 
YuraZ писал(а) >>
All indicators based on averages will suffer from "overshoot"
>> alas

--
but indicators based on levels do not suffer from this problem


But they draw a new level? This is also a re-drawing. IMHO.

 
SProgrammer писал(а) >> I don't ( at the moment ) have any answers in common.


They will not be. Redrawing is the opium of the people! On past data everything is fine - just a grail, and in the future - no one knows what will happen, certainly not a grail. ))))