Charles Dow's theory - page 5
You are missing trading opportunities:
- Free trading apps
- Over 8,000 signals for copying
- Economic news for exploring financial markets
Registration
Log in
You agree to website policy and terms of use
If you do not have an account, please register
You should first sort out where the stock market is and where the financial market is. They have completely different reasons for price formation. The TA for the stock market is different and for the financial market it is different. And there is no way to combine them into one TA.
Many, many years have passed since the Dow theory was developed. The world has accelerated and the theory in its original form has lost its relevance. Other laws are already working which were not seen by the developers of the Dow theory.
It will be commendable if you manage to improve the theory for today's realities).
It only remains to wish you success.
We must, immediately, reject the TA and FA axioms in their former formulation, as not having a firm theoretical basis, by methods, except the first axiom of the Dow in TA. I have not yet reached a verdict on the other 5 axioms of Dow and I have no right to say anything.
You see, in my country view, the guys operate with some otherworldly heavenly postulates at the level of Gunn, who left only mysteries, but he had a private plane and became a billionaire, and they say he got it from stock trading.
Yusuf, one formula, one science, where are the billions? I get dizzy when I read your articles and realize how far I am from your Moscow .... Respect! ..... But where are the billions? OK, I will never have them and I've accepted it a long time ago, but show it to me and when I see it, you will remain in my memory and the memory of my descendants as a living genius -....- mysterious and misunderstood by me.
It is clear that I write this sarcastically, because I see that no real exchange data is taken into account, the mathematical exchange model (as my friend Renka wrote) according to Blek-Scholes formula is not considered, and for these mathematicians and economists the financial power brokers even Nobel Prize was not spared, because the calculation of option values was a revolution in the market in favor of further enrichment of the rich and in favor of further redistribution of the Money to the Money.
Well, while Civilization is moving on the "right" capitalist course - already 67% of world capital is in private hands..... those names are well-known, because there are not many of themand as soon as, Yusuf, your formulas will work, the Crowd will leave the Puppeteers as skinny as Koschey the Immortal and your life will be in danger. There have been historical attempts at socialist redistribution of values, but they were successfully suppressed. For the aforementioned reason we are once again teetering on the edge of an equally global crisis as World War II and the Bretton Woods Treaty. It seems to me personally that there will not be a complete catastrophe, like the Great Depression, and we will end up trading in a new reserve currency, the Yuan, because they have clearly slept through China.
In short, Yusuf, I do not believe in logically correct universal formulations, because there is deliberate manipulation in the markets. So, start from this in your works or you will hang in the traders' museum on the place of honour next to Gunn......... What do we mortals know about it.
Yusuf, one formula, one science, where are the billions?
Whatbillions? IfYusuf is right, speculative profits are impossible!
Then why is this thread here? We are speculators here, aren't we? Then it turns out that Yusuf's work is worthy of a scientific journal and a title at the Academy of Sciences and has nothing to do with market speculation.
I am not criticizing or challenging anything, I am trying to redirect all of Yusuf's analytical power to our everything - successful speculation in the markets.
Whatbillions? IfYusuf is right, speculative profits are impossible!
Yes, it has been saidhttp://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/358795/page14#comment_19961760 previouslyhttps://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/357540/page7#comment_19718080,https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/357540/page11#comment_19758633
https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/358795/page14#comment_19964240
Then why is this topic here?
Then why is this topic here? We are speculators here, aren't we? Then it turns out that Yusuf's work is worthy of a scientific journal and a title at the Academy of Sciences and has nothing to do with market speculation.
I am not criticizing or challenging anything, I am trying to redirect all of Yusuf's analytical power to our everything - successful speculation in the markets.
I will think about it and leave a window for trading.
You see, in my country view, the guys operate with some otherworldly heavenly postulates at the level of Gunn, who left only mysteries, but he had a private plane and became a billionaire, and they say he got it from stock trading.
Yusuf, one formula, one science, where are the billions? I get dizzy when I read your articles and realize how far I am from your Moscow .... Respect! ..... But where are the billions? OK, I will never have them and I've accepted it a long time ago, but show it to me and when I see it, you will remain in my memory and the memory of my descendants as a living genius -....- mysterious and misunderstood by me.
It is clear that I write this sarcastically, because I see that no real exchange data is taken into account, the mathematical exchange model (as my friend Renka wrote) according to Blek-Scholes formula is not considered, and for these mathematicians and economists the financial power brokers even Nobel Prize was not spared, because the calculation of option values was a revolution in the market in favor of further enrichment of the rich and in favor of further redistribution of the Money to the Money.
Well, while Civilization is moving on the "right" capitalist course - already 67% of world capital is in private hands..... those names are well-known, because there are not many of themand as soon as, Yusuf, your formulas will work, the Crowd will leave the Puppeteers as skinny as Koschey the Immortal and your life will be in danger. There have been historical attempts at socialist redistribution of values, but they were successfully suppressed. For the aforementioned reason we are once again teetering on the edge of an equally global crisis as World War II and the Bretton Woods Treaty. It seems to me personally that there will not be a complete catastrophe, like the Great Depression, and we will end up trading in a new reserve currency, the Yuan, because they have clearly slept through China.
In short, Yusuf, I do not believe in logically correct universal formulations, because there is deliberate manipulation in the markets. So, start from that in your works or you will hang in the traders' museum on a place of honour next to Gunn......... What do we mortals get out of it I do not know.
Thanks for the good wishes.
I'll think about it and leave a window for trading.
Thank you for that. Because you have upset all the speculators here.