will the FOREX live on? - page 12

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

the next day, one day you are trading in profits, and they start sending you joyful emails (hello to Australians, by the way, bank forex): "Oh, you have a good trading system, congratulations".

bang the next day you get an "A-book" with a mile of slippage, we decided to move you to "real" liquidity.

Well, be glad that you have been given to trade in actually greenhouse conditions, that is, to make part of your profit at the broker's expense, not at the expense of the market. With a normal broker you would have been on "A-book" conditions with slippages from the very beginning. And if you were a little less lucky, you wouldn't have been transferred anywhere, you just wouldn't have been given your money. You have to think about where you open the account and what happens in the account

 
Boris Gulikov:

It doesn't matter.

Why do you have such a strong aversion to forex brokers?

)) There are no brokers in forex, they don't exist in nature.
 
Ilya Malev:

So be glad that you were given some time to trade in virtually greenhouse conditions, i.e. to make some of your profits not at the expense of the market, but at the expense of the broker. With a normal broker you would have been on "A-book" terms with slippages from the beginning.

How can there be slippages of 5 spreads, Carl? in the most liquid market in the world

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

Why the slippage of 5 spreads, Carl? In the most liquid market in the world

If it's on the news, it's fine. Even at 5, even at 25. Because there are thousands of people like you who want to get this price, but only a handful of people who are willing to give it to you.

 
Ilya Malev:

If it's on the news, that's fine. Because there are thousands of people like you out there who want the price, but there are only a handful of people who want to give you the price.

why limiters are slipping on the A-book, ..... Carl, are you still with us?

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

why limiters are slipping on the A-book, .... Carl, are you still with us?

Where are they sliding to? If on the plus side, it's a very good A-book. If in the negative, then you really have fallen for cheaters (unless you have specifically asked for such terms in the A-book)

 
Yuriy Asaulenko:
)) There are no brokers in forex, there are none in nature.

))) It doesn't matter. In common parlance, everyone is a "broker".

 
Ilya Malev:

Where do they slide? If on the plus side, it's a very good A-book. If it's negative, then you've really fallen for cheaters (unless you specifically asked for such conditions in the LC).

ok, why do they all slide except for DDE and the kitchen stuff in the lc? why can't they just do it the normal way?

 
Maxim Dmitrievsky:

ok, why do they all slide except DDE and the kitchen attachments in the LC?

Limiters can't slide into the negative. Maybe you're referring to stop-loss orders after all?
 
Boris Gulikov:
Limiters cannot slide into minus. Maybe you're talking about stop-loss orders after all?

What do you mean they can't? ))) that's the only way it happens in forex on ECN