Do you have any tactics for dealing with the loca? - page 31

 
kharko:

My approach is simple and does not require any calculations. But it may contradict the DC rules on execution time....

Netting system is a significant limitation for the TS...


OK, let's look at

You wrote

Thought. I need to open one more position at 1.2400... Total cumulative equals 4 lots at 1.2250...

You can see the calculations to see how it turned out

 
Mischek:


You can see the calculations to see how it turned out

(1 lot * 1.2100 + 1 lot * 1.2200 + 1 lot * 1.2300 + 1 lot * 1.2400) / 4 lots = 1.2250
 

Okay. Let's start at the beginning, guys.

Here's the picture.

Opened sell 1 lot

Barama 10 and later tried to open buy 1 lot.

We're working on a netting platform. What happens?

(answer: we should get 4683 pips in five digits)

 

already counted...

Why start at the beginning? Just reread part of the thread.

;)

 
kharko:
(1 lot * 1.2100 + 1 lot * 1.2200 + 1 lot * 1.2300 + 1 lot * 1.2400) / 4 lot = 1.2250


now you close 2 lots and take a profit of 300 pips in your balance

but you could open 100 lots at 1.2400 and then close the corresponding amount, getting the same 300 points on your balance

the question - why to open, if you need to fix 300 points if it is more economical not to open anything, and just close 1.5 lots

 
joo:

Okay. Let's start at the beginning, guys.

Here's the picture.

Opened sell 1 lot

Barama 10 and later tried to open buy 1 lot.

We're working on a netting platform. What happens?

(answer: we should get 4683 pips in five digits)


Andrei, you are too lazy to recalculate the netting yourself, yesterday Gans-deGlucker even recalculated it for you, now you are too lazy to read his spreadsheet
 
joo:

All right. Let's start at the beginning, guys.

Here's the picture.

Opened sell 1 lot

Barama 10 and later tried to open buy 1 lot

We are working on a non-trading platform. What will happen?

(Answer: should get 4683 pips of five digits)

Opened sell - 1 lot short

Later 10 bars tried to buy 1 lot, because there was a buy signal - so, nothing was opened. Profit 1.24134 - 1.21485 = 0.02649

Eight more bars later the buy signal - 1 lot long.

13 bars later the signal to sell - in total nothing is open. Profit 1.23918 - 1.21884 = 0.02034

Total 0.04683 profit.

 
Mischek:


now you close 2 lots and fix a 300 pips profit in your balance

but you could open 100 lots at 1.2400 and then close the corresponding amount, getting the same 300 points on your balance

the question - why to open a position, if you need to fix 300 points, if it is more economical to close 1.5 lots and not to open anything at all?


this is an example for a matte. full mt4 emulation.

And the question of the efficiency of a "stupid" deal once again shows the advantages of netting (MT5).

Timbo explained it here too...

I don't know who else is needed.

S-progger is already foaming at the mouth...

;)

 
joo:

All right. Let's start at the beginning, guys.

Here's the picture.

Opened sell 1 lot

Barama 10 and later tried to open buy 1 lot.

We're working on a netting platform. What happens?

(answer: should be 4683 pips five digits)


1 - sell 1 lot

2 at the lower blue point - close sell 1 lot

3 at the lower red point - buy 1 lot

4 from upper point blue - close buy 1 lot

close a sell order is a buy

close buy order is a sell

there is no closing in the market, there is only buying or selling

do not be confused by the word "CLOSE ORDER" on the button

 
Mischek:


now you close 2 lots and get 300 pips as a profit

but you could open 100 lots at 1.2400 and close the corresponding amount to get the same 300 points

the question - why do you need to open, if you need to fix 300 pips, if it is more economical to close 1.5 lots and not to open anything at all?

OK... We were looking at the ideal case where we have enough profit to lock in the balance sheet... What if for example there are 3 positions open with 1 lot at 1.2100, 1.2200 and 1.2300... The current price is 1.2200.... We want to close a profitable position at 1.2100... How do we do this in a netting system?