How can you prove that this is the real result of expert trading ?

New comment
 

It is surprising that there is no way to determine whether a trade is manual or expert .

Is it not possible to add an indication of the type of trade (manual or automatic) in the MT history or in the trading signals ?

Or is there?

 
Petros:

It is surprising that there is no way to determine whether a trade is manual or expert .

Is it not possible to add an indication of the type of trade (manual or automatic) in the MT history or in the trading signals ?

Or is there?

Majik, frequency of trades opened, the general view of the visualisation of the trades on the chart.
 
in expert and magik can be set to 0 - not an option
 
sanyooooook:
majik, frequency of open trades, the general view of the visualization of trades on the chart.

If a programmer or analyst does it. But that's not proof either. For example, my robot has no magic, and there are no fixed parameters. During trading they are always changing, and the frequency of open trades, and the number of pips, lot size, trade size, etc., from the history it is so not easy to determine that this is the result of trading a robot.

And if it's a simple Expert Advisor buyer,not everyone knows howto analyse historical data.

 
Petros:

It is surprising that there is no way to determine whether a trade is manual or expert .

Is it not possible to add an indication of the type of trade (manual or automatic) in the MT history or in the trading signals ?

Or is there?

And if automatic+manual, how can you tell ?
 
Petros:

If a programmer or analyst does it. But that's not proof either. For example, my robot has no magic, and there are no fixed parameters. During trading they are always changing, and the frequency of open trades, and the number of pips, lot size, trade size, etc., from the history it is so not easy to determine that this is the result of trading a robot.

And if it's a simple Expert Advisor buyer,not everyone knows how toanalyse historical data.

If you want to see the terminal logs that the Expert Advisor traded on, show them to anyone who is interested,

If it is a simple buyer of a robot, not everyone knows how to analyse historical data.

 
attach the logs of the terminal and the Expert Advisor from the Expert folder - all the records are there, if a person needs to understand what is what, the logs have evidence that it was a robot that opened these trades, not a human
 
sanyooooook:
provide logs or show logs of the terminal the Expert Advisor is or has been trading on
:-)
 
server:
And if automatic+manual, how can you tell ?

What am I suggesting?Couldn't the MT history or the trading signals have an indication of the type of trade (manual or automatic)?

From that we can determine.

 
Vladon:
:-)
Are you sure you can see it in the logs?
 
Petros:

What am I suggesting?Couldn't the MT history or the trading signals have an indication of the type of trade (manual or automatic)?

From this you can tell.

The brokerage company knows whether you are trading manually or robotically.

Do you also want to be informed if you opened the order manually or using a robot?

Do you have a split personality? One person should understand what the other is doing?

So use a robot to open orders with one comment on the order -- and use your hands to open orders with a different comment.

And then -- both personalities will be happy with each other.

123456789
New comment