What is a PUPPET? - page 5

New comment
 
KffAlex: What about Bloomberg or Reuters? They have no desire to enter quotes either?! Turn it on or go to RBC. Where are the 5 "official" signs?
Exactly. You also didn't answer the question about A-Forex.
 

Gentlemen! Thank you all for the heated discussion on this issue! After reading the posts, I am left with only one question: "Who generates the fifth mark, on what grounds and on what grounds?" Officially, you won't find any 5th mark in official (exactly in official) sources!

It is my understanding that the centres generate this mark only for the sake of MINIFOREX. Accordingly, for the end user the 5th mark is the point and for the intermediate supplier the point is the 4th mark. Only why then do the centres not set the metatrader's internal variables correctly??? And this question is already up to the dealer.

 

TheXpert:

Yedelkin:

KffAlex: The forex chart reflects trades already executed

With what evidence can you confirm that ask and bid on forex are the results of "already executed trades"? :)

Lack of level 2.

О! To the point where "no second level" confirms that the current "ask and bid on the forex are the results of already executed trades".
 
KffAlex: I take it that the centres are only generating this sign for the sake of MINIFOREX.
You also forgot to calculate what the point is for "centres" to "generate this sign for the sake of MINIFOREX".
 
Yedelkin:
О! The "lack of a second level" confirms that "ask and bid in forex are the results of already executed trades".
To answer the question: Ask&Bid is the deviation prices at which the dealer or bank can offer you to make a deal, in order to make money (unfortunately not you, but the dealer). Forex is an inter-bank unregulated market, where, if you noticed, there is neither a market rate nor a volume of transactions, there is only the price (the fact) of the transaction made by banks (unknown by whom and unknown where, at least to you exactly). And if the bank buys from the bank, who takes this notorious spread? Nobody. No spread! No regulator no spread!!! It's an axiom!
Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Торговые константы / Виды заявок в стакане цен
Документация по MQL5: Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Торговые константы / Виды заявок в стакане цен
  • www.mql5.com
Стандартные константы, перечисления и структуры / Торговые константы / Виды заявок в стакане цен - Документация по MQL5
 
Yedelkin:
You also forgot to calculate what the point is for "centres" to "generate this sign for the sake of MINIFOREX".
Simple mathematics! To make the spread float from 1 to 2, for example, you have to enter a fifth sign. Then it may be 1.6 and 1.7. And if you want it to be 1.68, you will have to enter the sixth digit. And with four digits, it can only be a multiple of 1. And to justify the presence of a fifth digit, it must be filled in with something, so that's the answer!
 
KffAlex:

"Who generates the fifth mark, on what grounds and on what grounds?" Officially, you will not find any 5th digit in official (official) sources!

Example: it is not uncommon to find the following situation: let's say, a 4-digit broker maximum daily bid 1.2937, and the five-digit 1.29369 - any questions why is it so and not vice versa (1.29371)? :)

 
KffAlex:  To answer the question: Ask&Bid is the deviation prices at which a dealer or bank can offer you to make a trade at the current moment in time, in order to make money
Already good. I.e. Ask&Bid is, after all, an offer make of a deal and not the result of "already executed deals".
 

KffAlex:

Yedelkin: You also forgot to calculate what the point is for "centres" to "generate this sign for the sake of MINIFOREX".

The usual maths!

You still failed to calculate (you failed to provide the calculations) what is the point for the "centres" to "generate this sign for the sake of MINIFOREX". Exactly "for the sake of MINIFOREX".
 
A100:

Example: it is not uncommon to find the following situation: let's say a 4-digit broker maximum daily bid 1.2937, and the five-digit 1.29369 - any questions why so and not vice versa (1.29371)? :)

No questions with that ! ))))))))) I saw the real EURUSD chart on the St. Petersburg exchange terminal, when Fibo wanted to connect to them (by the way, the direction was correct), so it is so volatile, that one can hardly catch anything! The Fibo people admitted afterwards that they specifically filter the price arrivals. So everything is interesting when you do it!
12345678
New comment