Same Account, different MT5, different amount of real tick - page 2
You are missing trading opportunities:
- Free trading apps
- Over 8,000 signals for copying
- Economic news for exploring financial markets
Registration
Log in
You agree to website policy and terms of use
If you do not have an account, please register
You keep showing the "Date modified" of the files, but you should also be looking at "Date created" to see which is older.
Possible answers already given ...
Ok here is possibile to see also the creation date, 1 week seems the gap.
I attached also the fresh backtest log
Ok here is possibile to see also the creation date, 1 week seems the gap.
I attached also the fresh backtest log
CS 0 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : real ticks begin from 2018.01.02 00:00:00
28% :
CS 0 17:58:47.367 Ticks GBPNZD.r : real ticks begin from 2022.07.01 00:00:00
Not even talking about all the "no real ticks within a day" in the 100% "quality" loool. How this be 100% when so much real ticks are missing !?!
100% :
CS 0 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : real ticks begin from 2018.01.02 00:00:00
28% :
Not even talking about all the
no real ticks within a day
in the 100% "quality" loool. How this be 100% when so much real ticks are missing !?!
Hope some MetaQuotes engineer can enlighten us :) This is what I get from backtesting
There is no need for a MetaQuotes engineer to "enlighten" you. Alain has already answered you.
There is less available tick data on one compared to the other. Also the bad one is a "beta".
Stop using "beta" software and expecting it to work correctly. Stick to only officially released builds.
Hope some MetaQuotes engineer can enlighten us :) This is what I get from backtesting
Why do you need a MetaQuotes engineer ? It's pretty clear, you are lacking history ticks data.
And the 100% quality data is just "marketing".
From your "100%" data quality log :
CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - real ticks absent for 11 minutes out of 1391 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1345 minutes out of 1391 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - 219907 tick prices mismatch for 1345 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - real ticks absent for 3 minutes out of 1424 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1323 minutes out of 1424 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - 411723 tick prices mismatch for 1323 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - real ticks absent for 8 minutes out of 1401 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1181 minutes out of 1401 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - 596611 tick prices mismatch for 1181 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - real ticks absent for 6 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1263 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - 787707 tick prices mismatch for 1263 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - real ticks absent for 4 minutes out of 1427 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1256 minutes out of 1427 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - 971433 tick prices mismatch for 1256 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.764 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2023.01.06 23:59 - real ticks absent for 10 minutes out of 1432 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:43.441 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2023.04.28 23:59 - real ticks absent for 101 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 0 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : real ticks begin from 2018.01.02 00:00:00 CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks absent for 931678 minutes of 1302291 total minute bars, every tick generation used CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks discarded for 6368 minutes of 1302291 total minute bars, every tick generation used CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks absent for 649 whole days
100% "marketing" I would say. Your backtest are meaningless as they are using mostly generated ticks.
EDIT: for some reason the site removed the formatting of the log.
From your "100%" data quality log :
CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - real ticks absent for 11 minutes out of 1391 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1345 minutes out of 1391 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.028 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.06 23:59 - 219907 tick prices mismatch for 1345 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - real ticks absent for 3 minutes out of 1424 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1323 minutes out of 1424 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.078 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.13 23:59 - 411723 tick prices mismatch for 1323 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - real ticks absent for 8 minutes out of 1401 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1181 minutes out of 1401 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.185 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.09.29 23:59 - 596611 tick prices mismatch for 1181 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - real ticks absent for 6 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1263 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.342 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.24 23:59 - 787707 tick prices mismatch for 1263 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - real ticks absent for 4 minutes out of 1427 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - real ticks discarded for 1256 minutes out of 1427 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:42.371 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2022.10.27 23:59 - 971433 tick prices mismatch for 1256 minute bars CS 3 18:01:42.764 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2023.01.06 23:59 - real ticks absent for 10 minutes out of 1432 total minute bars within a day CS 3 18:01:43.441 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2023.04.28 23:59 - real ticks absent for 101 minutes out of 1415 total minute bars within a day CS 0 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : real ticks begin from 2018.01.02 00:00:00 CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks absent for 931678 minutes of 1302291 total minute bars, every tick generation used CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks discarded for 6368 minutes of 1302291 total minute bars, every tick generation used CS 3 18:01:43.740 Ticks GBPNZD.r : 2020.01.01 00:00 - 2023.07.01 00:00 real ticks absent for 649 whole days
100% "marketing" I would say. Your backtest are meaningless as they are using mostly generated ticks.
EDIT: for some reason the site removed the formatting of the log.
Marketing done by whom? By MetaQuotes? By the Brokers? I don’t get the sense. If I see a data that does not correspond to reality for me it is a "Bug", not Marketing.
I have never requested Beta versions, if I have the Build 3815 installed this can be due to: or MetaQuotes show me that like a current release, or the Broker when I downloaded the platform. I never use Beta software.
However in my opinion it simply depends on the use made of the platform, the one with Real Tick 28% is less used than the one with 100%, so using it more maybe will also come to report 100% Real Tick.
Thanks for your time anyway.
Marketing done by whom? By MetaQuotes? By the Brokers? I don’t get the sense. If I see a data that does not correspond to reality for me it is a "Bug", not Marketing.
I have never requested Beta versions, if I have the Build 3815 installed this can be due to: or MetaQuotes show me that like a current release, or the Broker when I downloaded the platform. I never use Beta software.
However in my opinion it simply depends on the use made of the platform, the one with Real Tick 28% is less used than the one with 100%, so using it more maybe will also come to report 100% Real Tick.
Thanks for your time anyway.
Don't take it literally, I used quotes around "marketing", and I explained clearly why I did it.
If you want to report a bug, you are free to do it.
With Fernando we explained you why you had different amount of ticks. I don't understand your "anyway", I am just someone who takes time to explain you what you was not understanding or knowing. I don't deserve an "anyway".
Don't take it literally, I used quotes around "marketing", and I explained clearly why I did it.
If you want to report a bug, you are free to do it.
With Fernando we explained you why you had different amount of ticks. I don't understand your "anyway", I am just someone who takes time to explain you what you was not understanding or knowing. I don't deserve an "anyway".
Yes I will contact the tech support and also the Broker to understand why it gives 100% Real Ticks if it's not like that, clearly from the logs. I will let you know in case of news.
Thanks very much :)