Hello, sorry to everyone who is in the same boat here.
Could have been such a nice system, around 10-15% plus per month with low drawdown….
I am a beginner and not a good trader, hence me subscribing to systems - but I once made myself a “mental rule”: using the example of GBPUSD, lets assume I felt that GBPUSD was “too high” and I opened a short position, but then GBPUSD kept rising, I then opened a 2nd or possibly 3rd short position… but it still kept rising that I then had to seriously ask me – certainly after the 3rd short - if I was on the wrong side of the trend and I need to open LONG positions instead?! - Shame that she never followed that kind of principle!! She has now 12 positions against the trend! in the past – I felt – that she had been on several occasions very lucky with her opening positions against the existing trend, - then there was release of economic news and GBPUSD suddenly reversed and traded in the direction of her positions.
I suspended subscription / unsubscribed as I have no idea what she is going to do next, perhaps even open more positions against the trend?? close most positions at a big loss?? according to other comments on her telegram channel (I am not on telegram) it seems she is emotionally quite fragile, not a good place to be for us to have confidence in her judgment. she should just either do nothing and hoping that GBPUSD will reverse, perhaps even add long positions, as GBPUSD might rise further - and hope for a reversal?
One would hope that in the next weeks/ months there would be a reversal, so at least we can exit with break-even. Hopefully GBPUSD wont rise much further, but then it might….
update 21 August - seems she has not learnt anything, adding short GBPUSD positions in strong uptrend. - currently 12 short positions against the trend! and soon 80% drawdown!!
update 23 August - so she added USD 100 so the drawdown does not reach 80% - incredible, now 14 short GBPUSD positions!
I think Elvira feeling upset, the more negative comments the more her emotion out of control. We should sympathize and comfort her, after all, she is human being and managing 10 different signals, everyone can choose to cut losses and stop signals. I think Elvira will make the right and responsible decision to more than 500 people staying with her. If you don't support her in difficult times, then do you deserve it in times of profit?
This signal is in the largest drawdown it has ever faced and many people are scared of losing their accounts. Elvira has been dead silent and has not provided any update to reassure her subscribers. In fact, she even deleted the entire history of the discussion group. Many trading rules have been violated, there are 12 open orders when the description states that there would be a max of 7. If you had used the recommended deposit of $250, your account would have blown by now. There is an uptrend on GBPUSD, and Elvira keeps adding more and more positions as the drawdown increases. I really hope the signal can recover, but I wish the author was better at communicating with the subscribers, especially since so many people have their money and accounts on the line.
I am very disappointed. you are a good trader but you earn 5 pips against hundreds of pips drawdown. Also, you open many positions at very close price. I hope this experience will help you to improve in the future.
Elvira - just be ok and do your best - I wish the best for all of us … I think you can find the way - even it can last a little longer … we believe in you and we can wait - now just survive somehow and than we can recover …
A Elvira foi uma excelente trader durante um ano e meio. Ela teve bons resultados no início, mas neste último mês mudou sua estratégia, cometendo um erro de decisão em uma operação, o que é normal neste mercado.
No entanto, ela não soube lidar com a pressão e ser humilde com seus clientes.
Minha orientação para ela é que não mude a estratégia de abrir mais de 7 ordens. Se for necessário, feche algumas delas com resultados negativos e espere um tempo antes de recomeçar as operações. Elvira, tenha mais calma ao falar com seus clientes!
Não há necessidade de fechar 100% das ordens com resultados positivos. O objetivo é gerenciar o risco e trazer lucro.
Desejo sucesso e que você consiga reverter a situação e ter ótimos resultados em suas operações. Estarei acompanhando e aguardando que você se estabilize emocionalmente para, quem sabe, considerar uma nova contratação do sinal.
Csaba Vas
2024.07.12 19:06
(수정됨 2024.07.12 19:07) #
Update 12.07.24 - now the "trader" announced on her Telegram channel that negative comments make her angry and expose our accounts to danger. Quite unbelievable, I've never seen a signal provider like this one. She lied to her followers multiple times, but instead of reflecting on that, she threatens us not to make her angry. I guess we should celebrate the lying b*tch instead...
This "trader" is basically a liar. She says in the description that the maximum number of trades in one session is 7. Now she has 8 or 9 open. In a private chat she told me that the max DD is 30%, now it's nearly 45. In the description of her Starship (LOL) signal she says the max DD will be 15%, now it's more than 26.
Would you want to trust someone to handle your money who basically lies left right and centre, day and night? I don't think so.
Oh, and she is rude, even if you ask a simple question. Very emotional. Not good for a trader. I will not renew.
Hello, sorry to everyone who is in the same boat here.
Could have been such a nice system, around 10-15% plus per month with low drawdown….
I am a beginner and not a good trader, hence me subscribing to systems - but I once made myself a “mental rule”: using the example of GBPUSD, lets assume I felt that GBPUSD was “too high” and I opened a short position, but then GBPUSD kept rising, I then opened a 2nd or possibly 3rd short position… but it still kept rising that I then had to seriously ask me – certainly after the 3rd short - if I was on the wrong side of the trend and I need to open LONG positions instead?! - Shame that she never followed that kind of principle!! She has now 12 positions against the trend! in the past – I felt – that she had been on several occasions very lucky with her opening positions against the existing trend, - then there was release of economic news and GBPUSD suddenly reversed and traded in the direction of her positions.
I suspended subscription / unsubscribed as I have no idea what she is going to do next, perhaps even open more positions against the trend?? close most positions at a big loss?? according to other comments on her telegram channel (I am not on telegram) it seems she is emotionally quite fragile, not a good place to be for us to have confidence in her judgment. she should just either do nothing and hoping that GBPUSD will reverse, perhaps even add long positions, as GBPUSD might rise further - and hope for a reversal?
One would hope that in the next weeks/ months there would be a reversal, so at least we can exit with break-even. Hopefully GBPUSD wont rise much further, but then it might….
update 21 August - seems she has not learnt anything, adding short GBPUSD positions in strong uptrend. - currently 12 short positions against the trend! and soon 80% drawdown!!
update 23 August - so she added USD 100 so the drawdown does not reach 80% - incredible, now 14 short GBPUSD positions!
I think Elvira feeling upset, the more negative comments the more her emotion out of control. We should sympathize and comfort her, after all, she is human being and managing 10 different signals, everyone can choose to cut losses and stop signals. I think Elvira will make the right and responsible decision to more than 500 people staying with her. If you don't support her in difficult times, then do you deserve it in times of profit?
This signal is in the largest drawdown it has ever faced and many people are scared of losing their accounts. Elvira has been dead silent and has not provided any update to reassure her subscribers. In fact, she even deleted the entire history of the discussion group. Many trading rules have been violated, there are 12 open orders when the description states that there would be a max of 7. If you had used the recommended deposit of $250, your account would have blown by now. There is an uptrend on GBPUSD, and Elvira keeps adding more and more positions as the drawdown increases. I really hope the signal can recover, but I wish the author was better at communicating with the subscribers, especially since so many people have their money and accounts on the line.
I am very disappointed. you are a good trader but you earn 5 pips against hundreds of pips drawdown. Also, you open many positions at very close price. I hope this experience will help you to improve in the future.
Elvira - just be ok and do your best - I wish the best for all of us … I think you can find the way - even it can last a little longer … we believe in you and we can wait - now just survive somehow and than we can recover …
In the telegram channel she threaten people that :"IF YOU WRITE NEGATIVE COMMENTS I WILL MARGIN CALL YOU" .
she is a liar person who just think about her profit and even do not stand her principles...
Failed to keep to trading principles and never planned ahead when it came to knowing the UK elections were coming up.
A Elvira foi uma excelente trader durante um ano e meio. Ela teve bons resultados no início, mas neste último mês mudou sua estratégia, cometendo um erro de decisão em uma operação, o que é normal neste mercado.
No entanto, ela não soube lidar com a pressão e ser humilde com seus clientes.
Minha orientação para ela é que não mude a estratégia de abrir mais de 7 ordens. Se for necessário, feche algumas delas com resultados negativos e espere um tempo antes de recomeçar as operações. Elvira, tenha mais calma ao falar com seus clientes!
Não há necessidade de fechar 100% das ordens com resultados positivos. O objetivo é gerenciar o risco e trazer lucro.
Desejo sucesso e que você consiga reverter a situação e ter ótimos resultados em suas operações. Estarei acompanhando e aguardando que você se estabilize emocionalmente para, quem sabe, considerar uma nova contratação do sinal.
このシグナルを購読して１か月しかたっていませんので一度も利益を取れず資産の半分以上の含み損が発生しました。
明日更新日だが更新が出来ないので、来週から損切りするか立て直すか決めなければならない。
Update 12.07.24 - now the "trader" announced on her Telegram channel that negative comments make her angry and expose our accounts to danger. Quite unbelievable, I've never seen a signal provider like this one. She lied to her followers multiple times, but instead of reflecting on that, she threatens us not to make her angry. I guess we should celebrate the lying b*tch instead...
This "trader" is basically a liar. She says in the description that the maximum number of trades in one session is 7. Now she has 8 or 9 open. In a private chat she told me that the max DD is 30%, now it's nearly 45. In the description of her Starship (LOL) signal she says the max DD will be 15%, now it's more than 26.
Would you want to trust someone to handle your money who basically lies left right and centre, day and night? I don't think so.
Oh, and she is rude, even if you ask a simple question. Very emotional. Not good for a trader. I will not renew.