Collaborative project development in MQL5 - our future? - page 2

 
Alexey Volchanskiy:

Why, it will be the same as now on githab, collaborative development of non-commercial products.

But we have a commercial "environment". The specifics are special. How to deal with it?
 
Alexey Volchanskiy:

...collaborative development of non-commercial products.

I agree, for non-commercial projects this is the right thing to do. if the product is freely available, there will be no buyers for left-handed sources. stealing will not be possible.

with respect.

 
Andrey Kisselyov:
The company is developing an environment that is suitable for large programming projects and the development of Internet enterprises. In this environment, a person can live anywhere and be connected and work on this or that project using an interactive environment.

With respect.

So, the company is developing a technology that has nothing to do with trading, and it is announced at the forum of traders and alt traders? Some kind of logical inconsistency...

 
Реter Konow:

So, do you think that the development of collaborative technologies leads to the theft of ideas for all?

It does not rule it out, but based on the direction society is moving in, it makes it very likely.

With respect.

 
Реter Konow:

Please explain. "Unlawful receipt of natuaries", is an accusation of bad intentions. Perhaps I misunderstood.

So, according to you, the development of collaborative technologies leads to general theft of ideas?


In any software company you sign an NDA, violation is punishable by law. And the working group has access on the version control server only to their project and what is really needed.

 
Реter Konow:

So, the company is now developing a technology that has nothing to do with trading and announcing it on the forum of traders and algotraders? That's some kind of logical inconsistency...

or your misunderstanding of the issue.

The bus is designed to carry passengers, no one forbids traders to ride in the bus.

The company talks about their developments on their website, who can prohibit you from putting a banner on the wall in your home?

With respect.

 
Реter Konow:

So, the company is developing a technology that has nothing to do with trading, and it is being announced at the forum of traders and alt traders? This is some kind of logical inconsistency...


Don't twist things around, it is related to the development of trading software. The terminal, by and large, is also just software, a trading tool. It does not have any gems in it.

 
Andrey Kisselyov:

does not rule it out, but based on the direction of society's movement, makes that probability very high.

with respect.

With open access to developments, joint commercial projects become impossible. "Just" collaborative projects in forex are meaningless. So, the company should provide for the possibility of closed development and solve the problem of financial distribution between project participants. Then the theft of ideas and developments will be impossible. Isn't it?
 
Alexey Volchanskiy:

Don't twist things around, it is related to the development of trading software. The terminal, by and large, is also just software, a trading tool. It doesn't have any grails in it.

I quoted Andrey Kisselyov.

Read his post above.

Explain why the company is developing in this direction, don't you think? I cannot understand it in any way.

 
Реter Konow:
With open access to developments, joint commercial projects become impossible. 'Just' joint projects in the forecourt are meaningless. So, the company should provide for the possibility of closed developments and solve the problem of financial distribution between the project participants. Then the theft of ideas and developments will be impossible. Isn't it?

The company does not owe anyone anything, it makes the product for its own reasons and goals.

with respect.