Is it possible to code an EA for MT4, which would trade on the real as in the tester using control points? - page 4

 
paukas:

If you write a code to sell when the price has risen 20 pips from the bar opening, and you test using control points, then the EA in the test will sell at 20, 25, 30, 50, etc., depending on where the bar is high.

And in reality it will sell at 20. It's an unfair world out there.



Thank you, but, again, the question - how to implement this for reality? :) It turns out like chaos works in chaos. :)
 
M2012K:

Thank you, but, again, the question - how to implement this for reality? :)

Is it not already clear that there is no way?
 
Integer:

Is it not already clear that there is no way?

No, it is not clear, just like the proposed optimization in this mode in the tester, if it is possible, then it must be possible otherwise too. :) Simulate the same order (or mess) in real time
 
M2012K:

Thanks, but, again, the question - how to implement this for reality? :) ...
It's very complicated.
 
M2012K:

No, not clear, neither is the proposed optimisation in this mode in the tester, if it's possible, then it must be possible otherwise too. :)

Then I sympathise, what can be done.
 
paukas:
It's very difficult.



Don't talk nonsense please, it's impossible.
 
Integer:


Don't talk nonsense please, it's impossible.

Nothing is impossible. First you have to learn to see the future a bar ahead. The rest is nonsense.
 
paukas:

Nothing is impossible. First you have to learn to see the future a bar ahead. The rest is nonsense.


:)))

Here's where it gets interesting. In the process of creating and testing EAs, we prepare their cheating code in advance, don't we? :)

 
M2012K:


:)))

This is where it gets interesting. In the process of creating and testing EAs, we prepare their cheating code in advance, don't we? :)


If there is an absence in advance, you should take note and note the fact.
 
paukas:

If you write a code to sell when the price has risen 20 pips from the bar opening, and you test using control points, then the EA in the test will sell at 20, 25, 30, 50, etc., depending on where the bar is high.

And in reality it will sell at 20. It's an unfair world out there.



Question on your post - "the expert in the test will sell at 20, 25, 30, 50, etc., depending on where the bar is high," it turns out if you enter in the code to sell AFTER 20 with " sell at 20, 25, 30, 50, etc., depending on where the bar is high," then the assumption will happen a typical situation as in the tester? To rule out the option of "And in reality will sell at 20". ?