invalid book transaction - page 3

 
prostotrader:

Where is the guarantee that after"invalid book transaction" the quotes in the betting machine are correct?

I can repeat the previous message again.

 
fxsaber:

I can repeat the previous message one more time.

Off to bed...

 
prostotrader:

Doesn't start working again after an error. Apparently OnBookEvent stops working and ... hiccup.

That's what I'm asking. How can I check if the data in the glass is "broken"?

Added by

Just last month 1274"invalid book transaction" errors(see attachment)

The most clumsy variant - if the glass does not move for X seconds, then restart the Expert Advisor (or terminal if you want it to work).

 
fxsaber:

Compare bid/ask from SymbolInfoTick with bid/ask of the tumbler. Because of the misalignment, this must not be done head-on.

Cool! The basic data has to be double-checked!

Nothing can be higher!

 
Aleksey Vyazmikin:

The most clumsy option is to restart the Expert Advisor (or the terminal, if you want it to come to life) if the market doesn't move for X seconds.

Have you never traded illiquid futures?

The market may not "move" for hours there.

 
prostotrader:

Haven't you ever traded illiquid futures?

The market may not "move" for hours there.

Just recently I bought Si-9.19 by accident (I pressed buy on the glue) - I couldn't sell it for two days, but I closed in the black :)

Nah, trading low-liquid is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me.

I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation.

You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server?

 
Aleksey Vyazmikin:

Just recently bought Si-9.19 by accident (clicked buy on the glue) - couldn't sell for two days, but closed on the upside :)

Nah, trading low liquidity is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me.

I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation.

You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server?

Robots (Expert Advisors) are written not to sit behind a computer all the time.

The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less THE TERMINAL'S WINE!

 
prostotrader:

Robots (advisors; experts) are written so that you don't have to sit at your computer all the time.

The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less a TERMINAL fault!

Not constructive :)

I'm not saying that the fact you describe is normal.

I am interested, in order to understand how you can minimize the risks of such a phenomenon.

 
Doesn't reconnecting to another server help? In theory, it might...
 
Dmitriy Skub:
Doesn't reconnecting to another server help? In theory, it might...

No, restarting the terminal helps :(

2018.07.19 17:23:25.188 Books   invalid book transaction [CL-8.18,sell,68.56000,0]
2018.07.19 17:43:30.051 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-6.19,sell,74.78000,0]
2018.07.19 17:43:31.739 Books   invalid book item[BR-2.19,buy,70.51000,-1]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.161 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,buy,2277.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.162 Books   invalid book item[GOLD-9.18,buy,1222.70000,-3]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.162 Books   invalid book item[MIX-9.18,sell,228450.00000,-1]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.163 Books   invalid book transaction [VTBR-9.18,buy,4807.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.164 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-3.19,sell,23519.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.169 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-1.19,sell,75.98000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.243 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-3.19,buy,63301.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.373 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-3.19,sell,247375.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.393 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-12.18,sell,21815.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.428 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-12.18,buy,216500.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.428 Books   invalid book transaction [GAZR-12.18,sell,14269.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.471 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64202.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.554 Books   invalid book transaction [UCHF-12.18,buy,0.96320,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.602 Books   invalid book transaction [LKOH-12.18,buy,39278.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books   invalid book transaction [GAZR-9.18,buy,13894.00000,4][buys: 21, sells: 20, depth: 20]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books   invalid book transaction [GAZR-3.19,buy,13620.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-3.19,sell,119490.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books   invalid book transaction [ROSN-12.18,sell,43229.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books   invalid book transaction [ROSN-3.19,buy,36921.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.644 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.19,buy,64560.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.644 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-3.20,buy,63746.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.683 Books   invalid book transaction [PLD-12.18,buy,813.60000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.724 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-9.18,sell,21039.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:03.917 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-12.18,buy,17686.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:04.149 Books   invalid book transaction [TRNF-12.18,buy,153248.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:04.170 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-12.18,buy,71.54000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:04.351 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-5.19,buy,71.31000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:04.947 Books   invalid book transaction [GOLD-6.19,buy,1196.70000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:05.017 Books   invalid book transaction [UCAD-12.18,buy,1.28960,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:05.870 Books   invalid book transaction [Eu-3.19,buy,76310.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:06.299 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-6.19,sell,67714.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:24.028 Books   invalid book transaction [UJPY-12.18,buy,108.25000,0]
2018.07.19 19:05:24.107 Books   invalid book item[ED-9.18,sell,1.16620,-17]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books   invalid book transaction [GAZR-9.18,sell,13907.00000,18][buys: 20, sells: 21, depth: 20]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-9.18,sell,228250.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,sell,2283.15000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.892 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-12.18,sell,111990.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.892 Books   invalid book transaction [GOLD-9.18,buy,1222.40000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:13.894 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-9.18,sell,17958.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:14.312 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-9.18,buy,72.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:14.340 Books   invalid book transaction [GOLD-12.18,sell,1243.90000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:14.870 Books   invalid book item[SBRF-9.18,sell,21009.00000,-4]
2018.07.19 19:06:15.264 Books   invalid book transaction [CL-8.18,buy,68.01000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:18.200 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-3.19,sell,73.45000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:18.474 Books   invalid book transaction [ED-12.18,buy,1.17360,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:20.009 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-3.19,sell,113140.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:24.281 Books   invalid book transaction [Eu-12.18,sell,75920.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:27.711 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64608.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:27.795 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-12.18,sell,21484.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:28.261 Books   invalid book item[ED-9.18,buy,1.16560,-233]
2018.07.19 19:06:36.833 Books   invalid book transaction [UJPY-9.18,buy,110.73000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:39.432 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-2.19,sell,75.08000,0]
2018.07.19 19:06:43.291 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-11.18,buy,72.29000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:08.263 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-10.18,sell,72.65000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:10.624 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-4.19,sell,77.52000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:26.115 Books   invalid book transaction [PLT-9.18,buy,805.70000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:26.494 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-3.19,sell,238725.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:32.084 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-12.18,buy,226800.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:35.789 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-6.19,buy,111760.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:36.896 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-12.19,sell,113070.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:47.705 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-12.18,sell,73.91000,0]
2018.07.19 19:07:50.304 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-9.19,sell,112370.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:08:06.762 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-6.19,buy,20816.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:08:17.008 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-3.20,buy,111100.00000,0]
2018.07.19 19:09:02.512 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-6.19,buy,2173.80000,0]
2018.07.19 19:09:22.861 Books   invalid book transaction [UCHF-9.18,sell,0.99690,0]