Limit order slippage statistics on the exchange - page 6

 
MQ Alexander:

More precisely - for exchange instruments Limit orders placed at a better market price(higher Ask for BuyLimit and lower Bid for SellLimit) will be executed (activated) immediately after being placed (without waiting for the next price) at the current market price (Ask for BuyLimit, Bid for SellLimit).

Not strictly over/under.


Thank you for improving the tester. While you are at it, maybe you could think about it.

Forum on trading, automated trading systems and strategy testing

Limit order slippage statistics on the exchange

fxsaber, 2016.09.08 17:43

For what reason does this only apply to exchange traded instruments? On FOREX in the tester, positive limit order slippages introduce very decent distortions. You will say that positive ones happen there. Of course they do. But there are also requotes which are not present in the tester (arbitrary delay is not an option). Bottom line is that mathematically on any real account (due to requotes in limit orders) slippage is not only zero but cannot even compensate losses due to requotes - we lose summarily.

In other words, positive slippage in the tester without requotes is an embellishment of the real situation. Please think on this topic. If you need some constructive proof of any assertions - I'm open to it. With all due respect, positive slippages in the FOREX tester should be removed too. This only applies to limit orders. Who needs these slippages, let them use market orders and continue to rejoice in tester grails. And for those who use limit orders, the current approach of their execution causes very serious distortions in the results.

Very overestimated results are obtained using limit orders in an MT5 tester when compared to reality. Therefore please make the execution of limit orders on FOREX the same as you would do on the stock exchange.
 
fxsaber:

Not strictly over/under.

Of course it is more than/less than or equal to.

Very overestimated results come out when using limit orders on FOREX in the MT5 tester, if you compare it with reality. Therefore please make the execution of limit orders on FOREX the same as you would do on the exchange.
There is no "right" way to do this, each of the variants has its advantages and disadvantages. No changes will be made in the near future.
 
MQ Alexander:

There is no 'right' option here, each of the behaviours has its advantages and disadvantages. No changes will be made in the near future.

Completely agree that there is no right one. However, anyone who wants a slip can achieve it with marques. But getting no limiters to slip is not. So I suggest a strawman solution.
 
MQ Alexander:

On the MQ-Demo MOEX-symbols slide!

 
fxsaber:

On the MQ-Demo MOEX-symbols slide!


Strange statement, Demo slides 8-O
 
Sergey Chalyshev:

Strange statement, Demo slides 8-O

In the context of the branch - Tester.

 
fxsaber:

In the context of the branch - Tester.


Screw him, with your capabilities you could have written your own tester a long time ago.
 
Sergey Chalyshev:

Forget about it, with your capabilities you could have written your own tester a long time ago.

It would help everyone if the MT5 tester took the place of a benchmark tester.

 
fxsaber:

It would help everyone if the MT5 tester took the honourable place of a benchmark tester.


The benchmark is different for everyone.

For a brokerage company it is useful for the tester to show the mountain of gold.

For the trader it is useful for the tester to show what he needs.

Who to adapt to?

 
fxsaber:

It would help everyone if an MT5 tester took the honourable place of a benchmark tester.

Do you, dear fellow, make any money on the real?

First the terminal should work properly, and then everything else.

GP      0       19:17:29.663    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167146 buy limit 3.00 UCHF-9.18 at market done in 132608.665 ms
HR      0       19:17:29.678    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167164 buy limit 3.00 AUDU-9.18 at market done in 132623.761 ms
HK      0       19:17:29.698    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167165 sell limit 3.00 AUDU-9.18 at market done in 132642.978 ms
OE      0       19:17:29.721    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167070 buy limit 1.00 GOLD-12.18 at market done in 132653.264 ms
NG      0       19:17:29.741    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167172 sell limit 1.00 ALRS-9.18 at market done in 132686.437 ms
MR      0       19:17:29.755    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167177 sell limit 2.00 NLMK-9.18 at market done in 132700.889 ms
HP      0       19:17:29.783    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167183 buy limit 1.00 PLT-12.18 at market done in 132727.785 ms
CO      0       19:17:29.801    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167254 sell limit 1.00 GMKR-9.18 at market done in 132746.755 ms
FN      0       19:17:29.819    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167689 sell limit 2.00 SBRF-12.18 at market done in 132722.855 ms
QJ      0       19:17:29.839    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167774 sell limit 3.00 UCHF-9.18 at market done in 132783.830 ms
GH      0       19:17:29.855    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167936 sell limit 2.00 MOEX-9.18 at market done in 132800.500 ms
EH      0       19:17:29.870    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167942 buy limit 1.00 SNGR-9.18 at market done in 132815.113 ms
IR      0       19:17:29.889    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167943 sell limit 2.00 SNGR-9.18 at market done in 132834.156 ms
KN      0       19:17:29.916    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85168487 buy limit 2.00 CY-9.18 at market done in 132860.907 ms
JP      0       19:17:29.935    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85168192 buy limit 3.00 UCAD-9.18 at market done in 132944.703 ms
KL      0       19:17:29.950    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85170324 sell limit 1.00 VTBR-9.18 at market done in 132895.471 ms
FJ      0       19:17:29.965    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85170435 sell limit 3.00 UJPY-9.18 at market done in 132910.178 ms
RE      0       19:17:29.979    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85167688 buy limit 1.00 SBRF-12.18 at market done in 132883.188 ms
KD      0       19:17:29.999    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85170988 sell limit 1.00 CHMF-9.18 at market done in 132943.997 ms
PN      0       19:17:30.021    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85171201 buy limit 1.00 ED-12.18 at market done in 133030.275 ms
DN      0       19:17:30.044    Trades  'xxxxx': cancel #85171303 buy limit 1.00 UJPY-9.18 at market done in 132989.636 ms