Удаленные ордера правого терминала.
Живой ордер от левого Терминала.
Смотрим его тикет и пробуем его (50327280160) найти в логах обоих Терминалов.
Левый.
2023.01.17 14:14:17.388 Experts expert Test5-3 (USDCNH,H1) loaded successfully 2023.01.17 14:14:23.545 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.649 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.805 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.869 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.085 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.231 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.343 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.586 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.637 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.739 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.843 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.937 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.042 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.075 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.075 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280159 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 done in 34.175 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:25.139 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280159 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.180 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280159 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:25.180 Trades '5009503753': failed cancel order #50327280159 buy 0 at market [Modification failed due to order or position being close to market] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.196 Experts expert Test5-3 (USDCNH,H1) removed
Правый.
2023.01.17 14:14:10.683 Experts expert Test5-3 (USDCNH,H1) loaded successfully 2023.01.17 14:14:23.545 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.649 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.805 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:23.869 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.084 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.232 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.342 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.586 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.637 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.739 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.842 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:24.936 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.041 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.075 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.075 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280159 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 done in 35.014 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:25.139 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280159 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79614 2023.01.17 14:14:25.178 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280159 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:25.178 Trades '5009503753': failed cancel order #50327280159 buy 0 at market [Modification failed due to order or position being close to market] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.240 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.337 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.442 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.643 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:25.744 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:27.158 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:27.265 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:27.361 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:28.185 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79618 2023.01.17 14:14:28.819 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79618 2023.01.17 14:14:28.819 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280275 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79618 done in 634.602 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:29.055 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280275 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79618 2023.01.17 14:14:29.091 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280275 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:29.091 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280275 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 36.085 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:29.181 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:29.274 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:29.353 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:29.459 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:29.547 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:29.760 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:30.664 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:30.771 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:30.883 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:31.020 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:31.080 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79603 2023.01.17 14:14:31.491 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79603 2023.01.17 14:14:31.491 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280378 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79603 done in 411.811 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:31.560 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280378 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79603 2023.01.17 14:14:31.595 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280378 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:31.706 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280378 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 146.247 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:33.083 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.166 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.271 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.364 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.467 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.580 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.727 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.761 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:33.869 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:34.067 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:34.101 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:34.102 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280457 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 done in 34.349 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:34.172 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280457 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:34.207 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280457 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:34.207 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280457 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 35.371 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:34.565 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:34.679 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:35.675 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:36.372 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:36.476 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:37.558 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:37.661 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:37.661 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280564 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 done in 103.160 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:37.697 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280564 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79544 2023.01.17 14:14:37.745 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280564 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:37.745 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280564 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 47.968 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:37.819 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:37.897 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:38.181 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:38.278 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:38.391 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:40.696 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79540 2023.01.17 14:14:40.741 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79540 2023.01.17 14:14:40.741 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280675 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79540 done in 45.934 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:40.789 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280675 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79540 2023.01.17 14:14:41.132 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280675 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:41.132 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280675 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 342.863 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:41.401 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:41.616 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:41.719 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:41.796 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:41.902 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:41.996 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:42.100 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:42.596 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:42.698 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:43.205 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 2023.01.17 14:14:45.627 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 2023.01.17 14:14:45.627 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280865 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 done in 2422.251 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:45.705 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327280865 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 2023.01.17 14:14:45.739 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327280865 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:45.739 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327280865 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 34.188 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:47.211 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:48.217 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:48.313 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:49.619 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79534 2023.01.17 14:14:49.926 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79534 2023.01.17 14:14:49.926 Trades '5009503753': order #50327281000 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79534 done in 307.097 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:50.324 Trades '5009503753': cancel order #50327281000 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79534 2023.01.17 14:14:50.362 Trades '5009503753': accepted cancel order #50327281000 buy 0 at market 2023.01.17 14:14:50.362 Trades '5009503753': cancel #50327281000 buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at market done in 38.432 ms 2023.01.17 14:14:50.437 Trades '5009503753': failed prices for 0 [Invalid request] 2023.01.17 14:14:55.441 Experts expert Test5-3 (USDCNH,H1) removed
Тикета нет, он не приходил в OnTradeTransaction! Это по теме, что OnTradeTransaction ничего не пропускает...
Прошу еще обратить внимание на подобные задержки.
Форум по трейдингу, автоматическим торговым системам и тестированию торговых стратегий
OrderSend возвращает неправильный тикет
fxsaber, 2023.01.17 14:05
2023.01.17 14:14:43.205 Trades '5009503753': buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 2023.01.17 14:14:45.627 Trades '5009503753': accepted buy stop 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 2023.01.17 14:14:45.627 Trades '5009503753': order #50327280865 buy stop 0.1 / 0.1 USDCNH at 6.79533 done in 2422.251 ms
Пинг 32 мс.
Исправили, будет в очередной бете
Ошибка была в том, что в одно и то же время два терминала посылали две одинаковые заявки и они сливались в очереди.
Вы упускаете торговые возможности:
- Бесплатные приложения для трейдинга
- 8 000+ сигналов для копирования
- Экономические новости для анализа финансовых рынков
Регистрация
Вход
Вы принимаете политику сайта и условия использования
Если у вас нет учетной записи, зарегистрируйтесь
После прочтения свежей темы задумался о теоретической возможности там сказанного, когда OrderSend на разных терминалах одного счета получили один и тот же тикет (Result.order).
Раньше об этом не задумывался, но теоретическое обоснование нашел, когда подумал об этом параметре.
Соответственно, решил проверить гипотезу через такой советник.
Ну и теперь подготовка. Берем два терминала и подключаем к одному торговому счету. Перезагружаем оба и не делаем никаких торговых операций - синхронизация Result.id.
Взял MetaQuotes-Demo, оставил в Обзоре рынка только USDCNH (большой тиковый объем) и накинул на его чарт советник на каждом терминале.
На первом чарте входной Magic=1, второй Magic = 2. После чего нажал на обоих терминалах кнопку OK (без задержек).
И вот, что получил.
Оба Терминала получили один и тот же Result.order после OrderSend! При этом один терминал завершил работу, т.к. мэджик, который был указан в OrderSend, оказался не соответствующим ордеру, что вернул этот OrderSend.
Журнал обоих терминалов.
Отличие записей только в длительности выполнения OrderSend.
Автор исходной ветки из-за этого бага получил заметный убыток, т.к. произошла потеря своего ордера в логике. Баг, очевидно, носит критический характер.
Более широко (разные символы, разные Result.id) не проверял. Для воспроизведения и разбирательства все есть.
Строка для поиска: Oshibka 060.