My dissatisfaction to the strategy tester. to the MQL developers - page 6

 
Can these formulaic synthetics be traded in the tester ?
 

  1. Is it possible to use formula and normal custom symbols in formulas? If so, how do you avoid looping?
  2. Is it possible to change the formula on the fly - rebalancing synthetics? If so, what happens to the history?

 
pivomoe:
Can these formula synthetics be traded in the tester ?

It is possible to create a normal custom symbol based on a formula symbol for the tester.

But technically, nothing prevents you from not making formula synthetics tradable in the tester.

 

fxsaber, you are early in your evaluation of synthetics

At this stage have laid the groundwork for them as I understand it

Now they will be polished.

And on funds this strategy is one of the most profitable...

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

fxsaber, you are early in your evaluation of synthetics

Where?

 
fxsaber:

Where?

Above is the discussion.

Wait at least a month or two.

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Above is the discussion.

Wait at least a month or two.

There are only questions there. No need to try and read between the lines.

 
fxsaber:

There are only questions there. There is no need to try to read between the lines.

ok
 
Renat Fatkhullin:
Building the history of minute bars
...

The history of the minute bars of a synthetic instrument is calculated based on the minute bars (not ticks) of the instruments included in its formula. For example, to calculate the price of an Open Minute Bar of a synthetic instrument, the platform takes the prices of the Open instruments included in its formula. Similar calculations are made for High, Low and Close prices.

But that's not right, the high and low of different instruments can be at completely different times.

The tick history generation was abandoned in favour of speed, it is understandable, but aren't there plans to make such generation on demand? It is still much faster than our solution.

 
Andrey Khatimlianskii:

But this is wrong, because the highs and lows of different instruments can be at completely different times.

Thetick history generation was abandoned in favour of speed, it is understandable, but aren't there plans to make such generation on demand? It's still much faster than your own solution.


It says"In addition to collecting ticks in real time, the platform also generates a minute history of the synthetic instrument." We have to check if the ticks will be given by synthetic via CopyTick.