Testing 'CopyTicks' - page 14

New comment
 
Rashid Umarov:

For example

Slightly reworked

string GetTickFlag( uint tickflag )
{
  string flag = "";

#define  TICKFLAG_MACRO(A) flag += ((bool)(tickflag & TICK_FLAG_##A)) ? " TICK_FLAG_" + #A : "";
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(BID)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(ASK)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(LAST)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(VOLUME)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(BUY)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(SELL)
#undef  TICKFLAG_MACRO

  if (flag == "")
    flag = "FLAG_UNKNOWN";
     
  return(flag);
}

Result

2016.09.14 13:52:33.925 Test (Si-9.16,M1)       Tick23: time = 2016.09.13 18:52:35.505 bid = 0.0 ask = 0.0 last = 65253.0 volume = 35  TICK_FLAG_BID TICK_FLAG_ASK

It turns out that both prices change to zero from non-zero values. And after zeros go back to non-zeros.

 
fxsaber:

Indicator shows that CopyTicks may not be giving away the last ticks

Even more interesting

string GetTickFlag( uint tickflag )
{
  string flag = "";

#define  TICKFLAG_MACRO(A) flag += ((bool)(tickflag & TICK_FLAG_##A)) ? " TICK_FLAG_" + #A : "";
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(BID)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(ASK)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(LAST)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(VOLUME)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(BUY)
  TICKFLAG_MACRO(SELL)
#undef  TICKFLAG_MACRO

  if (flag == "")
    flag = " FLAG_UNKNOWN (" + (string)tickflag + ")";
     
  return(flag);
}

#define  TOSTRING(A) " " + #A + " = " + (string)Tick.A

string TickToString( const MqlTick &Tick )
{
  static int i = 0;
  
  i++;
  
  return("Tick" + (string)i + ":" + TOSTRING(time) + "." + (string)(Tick.time_msc %1000) +
         TOSTRING(bid) + TOSTRING(ask) + TOSTRING(last)+ TOSTRING(volume) + GetTickFlag(Tick.flags));
}

bool MySymbolInfoTick( const string Symb, MqlTick &Tick, const uint Type = COPY_TICKS_ALL )
{
  MqlTick Ticks[];
  const int Amount = ::CopyTicks(Symb, Ticks, Type, 0, 1);
  const bool Res = (Amount > 0);
  
  if (Res)
    Tick = Ticks[Amount - 1];
  
  return(Res);
}

#define  INDICATOR // Переключение между индикатором и экспертом

#ifdef  INDICATOR
  #define  NAME "Indicator: "

  #property indicator_chart_window
  #property indicator_buffers 0
  #property indicator_plots   0

  int OnCalculate( const int rates_total,
                   const int prev_calculated,
                   const datetime &time[],
                   const double &open[],
                   const double &high[],
                   const double &low[],
                   const double &close[],
                   const long &tick_volume[],
                   const long &volume[],
                   const int &spread[] )
#else
  #define  NAME "Expert: "

  void OnTick( void )
#endif
{
  MqlTick Tick1, Tick2;
  
  if (SymbolInfoTick(_Symbol, Tick1) && MySymbolInfoTick(_Symbol, Tick2))
    if (Tick1.time_msc != Tick2.time_msc)
      Print(NAME + ((Tick1.time_msc > Tick2.time_msc) ? "EventTime > CopyTicks_Time" : "EventTime < CopyTicks_Time") +
            "\nFrom Event: " + TickToString(Tick1) + "\nFrom CopyTicks: " + TickToString(Tick2) + "\n");

#ifdef  INDICATOR 
  return(rates_total);
#endif
}
Result
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From CopyTicks: Tick16: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:06.62 bid = 65013.0 ask = 65015.0 last = 65014.0 volume = 1 TICK_FLAG_LAST TICK_FLAG_VOLUME TICK_FLAG_SELL
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From Event: Tick15: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:06.68 bid = 65013.0 ask = 65015.0 last = 65014.0 volume = 1 TICK_FLAG_LAST TICK_FLAG_VOLUME TICK_FLAG_SELL
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      Indicator: EventTime > CopyTicks_Time
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From CopyTicks: Tick14: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:06.62 bid = 65013.0 ask = 65015.0 last = 65014.0 volume = 1 TICK_FLAG_LAST TICK_FLAG_VOLUME TICK_FLAG_SELL
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From Event: Tick13: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:06.68 bid = 65013.0 ask = 65015.0 last = 65014.0 volume = 1 TICK_FLAG_LAST TICK_FLAG_VOLUME TICK_FLAG_SELL
2016.09.14 14:25:24.533 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      Indicator: EventTime > CopyTicks_Time
2016.09.14 14:25:18.974 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      
2016.09.14 14:25:18.974 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From CopyTicks: Tick12: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:00.519 bid = 65011.0 ask = 65012.0 last = 65012.0 volume = 8 TICK_FLAG_LAST TICK_FLAG_VOLUME TICK_FLAG_BUY
2016.09.14 14:25:18.974 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      From Event: Tick11: time = 2016.09.14 14:25:00.510 bid = 65011.0 ask = 65012.0 last = 65012.0 volume = 8 FLAG_UNKNOWN (0)
2016.09.14 14:25:18.974 Test2 (Si-9.16,M1)      Indicator: EventTime < CopyTicks_Time

CopyTicks can both lag behind and be ahead of the Event-tick. Event-tick often has a zero flag.

ZZY Correct the MqlTick flag to flags in the MqlTick help.

 

How others use CopyTicks is beyond me. No trust, unfortunately. Very raw.

EA

#include <TypeToBytes.mqh> // https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/16280

void OnTick( void )
{
  static MqlTick PrevTick;  
  static int Amount = 0;
  
  MqlTick Ticks[];
  
  if (Amount > 0)
  {
    Amount = CopyTicks(_Symbol, Ticks, COPY_TICKS_ALL, PrevTick.time_msc);
    
    int i;
    
    for (i = 0; i < Amount; i++)
      if (_R(Ticks[i]) == PrevTick) // https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/16280
        break;
        
    if (i == Amount)
      Print("В истории (length = " + (string)Amount + ") нет тика, что был на предыдущем Event.");
  }
  else
    Amount = CopyTicks(_Symbol, Ticks, COPY_TICKS_ALL, TimeCurrent() * 1000);
    
  if (Amount > 0)
    PrevTick = Ticks[Amount - 1];  
}

Result

2016.09.15 11:04:02.810 Test2 (RTS-9.16,M1)     В истории (length = 2) нет тика, что был на предыдущем Event.
2016.09.15 11:03:59.312 Test2 (RTS-9.16,M1)     В истории (length = 13) нет тика, что был на предыдущем Event.
2016.09.15 11:03:59.290 Test2 (RTS-9.16,M1)     В истории (length = 1) нет тика, что был на предыдущем Event.

The tick that was in the history is already absent in the next Tick-event!

Dear developers, bring CopyTicks to a working condition. Even simple tests are failing.

 
At the moment CopyTicks with some stretch, but works in real time with input parameter from == 0.
 

I need to add new history ticks to the array on each OnTick. Has anyone implemented this?

I'm struggling - it's not working. I can't manage to bypass curvature of CopyTicks.

 
fxsaber:
At the moment CopyTicks with some stretch, but works in real time with input parameter from == 0.
Here is one of the stretches
void OnTick( void )
{
  MqlTick Ticks[];
  
  const int Amount = CopyTicks(_Symbol, Ticks);
  
  if ((Amount > 1) && (Ticks[Amount - 1].time_msc < Ticks[Amount - 2].time_msc))
    Print("Некорректная история!");
}
Result
2016.09.15 13:11:13.231 Test4 (RTS-9.16,M1)     Некорректная история!
2016.09.15 13:10:48.954 Test4 (RTS-9.16,M1)     Некорректная история!
We take the edge ticks, and find that the most recent tick has less time than the previous one.
 
fxsaber:
Here's one of the stretchesReceive the extreme ticks, and find that the most recent tick has a shorter time than the previous one.

Check out the code for this indicator

https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/94399/page6#comment_2776784

Таблица всех сделок. Доступ через MQL5
Таблица всех сделок. Доступ через MQL5
  • reviews: 1
  • www.mql5.com
Как организовать получение таблицы сделок? Пока не важно из индикатора или из советника...
 
fxsaber:
We take the extreme ticks, and find that the most recent tick has a shorter time than the previous one.
This applies only to COPY_TICKS_ALL. With the other modes, the suggested EA has not detected any errors.
 
Do I have to write to Service Desk about the reports in this thread or do the developers monitor it themselves?
 
fxsaber:
Do I have to write to Service Desk about the reports in this thread or do the developers monitor it themselves?
You'd better write to them. It won't be superfluous.
1...789101112131415161718192021...47
New comment