You are missing trading opportunities:
- Free trading apps
- Over 8,000 signals for copying
- Economic news for exploring financial markets
Registration
Log in
You agree to website policy and terms of use
If you do not have an account, please register
I was also thinking about it, in principle for indicator-based TS it would be enough to use NS as a predictor not of further price movement, but of a series of losses, i.e. to predict when indicators are trading at a profit and when they are at a loss
I was also thinking about it, in principle for indicator-based TS it would be enough to use NS as a predictor not of further price movement, but of a series of losses, i.e. to predict when indicators are trading at a profit and when they are at a loss
I would like to enliven the discussion and ask everyone involved to answer the following question: What do you think neural networks model in the market:
1. Hidden non-linear relationship between prices, or
2. The work of the trader's brain in making trading decisions based on incoming data.
gpwr:
Hidden non-linear relationship between prices, or
I would like to enliven the discussion and ask everyone involved to answer the following question: What do you think neural networks model in the market:
1. Hidden non-linear relationship between prices, or
2. The work of the trader's brain to make a trading decision based on incoming data.
What matters is what we feed into the neural network inputs. These should be significant factors that influence the price.
Well, if we make Mars weather as inputs and take EUR/USD quotes as outputs and train the neural network on them, then with a certain number of neurons and layers the neural network will find dependence.
But it will have nothing to do with reality.
As I was taught (a long time ago =) ) there are 3 types of inputs:
1. Inputs of which we know they exist, but cannot obtain or measure them in any way. In our case it is noise (interference).
2. Inputs that we can receive (including delayed) and measure.
3. The outputs of the system at previous moments in time. (If the system is dynamic, it depends on its previous states).
Imho:
1. the first type of inputs - cataclysms, terrorist acts, Central Bank interventions, actions of big players. We do not find out about them at all or we find out after the fact. We are not interested in them.
The second type - macroeconomic indicators (GDP, refinancing rate, etc.).
3. The price at time t depends on the prices at time t-1, t-2, ... t-n.
Amateurs of thechanalysis consider only type 3 inputs. Trend-followers believe that if the price moved in one direction, it will still move in the same direction. And how significant are inputs of this type? I think the price hardly depends on them by more than 5%.
P.S. If anyone here has tried to inputs of the 2nd type - macroeconomic indicators, please share the results. =)