Libraries: Dealing with time (2) functions - page 5

New comment
 

I have found a different solution.

I want to upload it, but the wheel keeps spinning and spinning...

So here are the indicator and the mqh file.

As the problem seems to be that at OnIni() CopyTime does not provide the values I need - sometimes - I do the time set in OnCalcutalte() (or OnTick()) ...

Feel free to check it and let me know what you think.

 
Now the new version is online.
 
Carl Schreiber #:
Now the new version is online.
It seems to be working on Saturday, Sunday and Monday as well now, even on my side so that's perfect.

I still have an incomprehension, that could be on my side, but if you can enlighten me after reading your guides multiple times without understanding, that would be awesome.

As said, I'm using FTMO, and they switched their DST on NY date (10 March) this year, but when the bot check for DST, instead of moving from +2 to +3 like it would normally do, it did move the GMT from +2 to +4, I'm still really not sure of why it does that. It's not really impactful for now as we're in April/May, but I'd like to understand what happens there.

Taking into consideration that when comes the European DST, it comes back to a more normal number, which is DST +3 (so going from +2 to +3, which is a normal DST switch),
I hope it was understandable. It's quite messy in my head right now, so I tried to make it clear

And as said in my first message, which was telling that I think it's a bug in the code, when I compared a trading hour with trading view putting my trading view time zone to UTC+0, it was off of 1 hour, so I guess that's a coding problem as well. It occurs from 11th of March to 30th of March I think, around that. For the whole NYSumEUWin
Libraries: Dealing with time (2) functions
Libraries: Dealing with time (2) functions
  • 2024.04.28
  • Carl Schreiber
  • www.mql5.com
Articles, Library comments: Libraries: Dealing with time (2) functions
 

Here are the various time states of the MQ-Demo account:

  1. EU & US in winter time                               Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -7200   sec => GMT: 2024.02.26 01:00  time area: US=Winter & EU=Winter
  2. EU in winter time & US in summer time     Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.03.20 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Winter
  3. EU & US in summer time                             Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.04.10 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Summer

Right now, at 07:24 in Vienna, MEZ (= UTC+2) my time indicator is showing on the chart:


And here are the logs of the debugger of the various time situations at 2024.03.03, 2024.03.10, 2024.03.21,  2024.04.01, 2024.04.11:

2024.04.29 07:06:20.291    2024.03.03 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.02.26 03:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.10 03:00  USD spr: second 10 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:06:20.943    2024.03.03 00:00:00   DST_EUR for 2024.02.26 03:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.31 03:00  EUR spr: last 31 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:06:21.988    2024.03.03 00:00:00   AUD-DST for 2024.02.26 03:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.04.07 03:00  AUD spr: first 7 Sunday  of April: 4
2024.04.29 07:07:15.377    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Mo., 2024.02.26 03:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:07:15.377    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -7200   sec => GMT: 2024.02.26 01:00  time area: US=Winter & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:07:15.377    2024.03.03 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 421199 sec or 116 h, close time: Fr., 2024.03.01 23:59
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -2 h = -7200 sec.
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Mo. 2024.02.26 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.02.25 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.03.01 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       421199 s  117.00 h
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Winter & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.03.10 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.03.31 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:07:15.617    2024.03.03 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00


2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.03.04 03:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.10 03:00  USD spr: second 10 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   DST_EUR for 2024.03.04 03:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.31 03:00  EUR spr: last 31 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   AUD-DST for 2024.03.04 03:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.04.07 03:00  AUD spr: first 7 Sunday  of April: 4
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Mo., 2024.03.04 03:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -7200   sec => GMT: 2024.03.04 01:00  time area: US=Winter & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 421199 sec or 116 h, close time: Fr., 2024.03.08 23:59
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -2 h = -7200 sec.
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Mo. 2024.03.04 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.03.03 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.03.08 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       421199 s  117.00 h
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Winter & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.03.10 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.03.31 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:09:59.969    2024.03.10 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:09:59.982    EURUSD : real ticks begin from 2011.12.19 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.03.11 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.11.03 03:00  USD aut: first 3 Sunday  of November: 11
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Mo., 2024.03.11 00:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.03.10 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 431999 sec or 119 h, close time: Fr., 2024.03.15 23:59
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -3 h = -10800 sec.
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Mo. 2024.03.11 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.03.10 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.03.15 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       431999 s  120.00 h
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.11.03 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.03.31 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:10:03.535    2024.03.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00


2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.03.21 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.11.03 03:00  USD aut: first 3 Sunday  of November: 11
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   DST_EUR for 2024.03.21 00:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.31 03:00  EUR spr: last 31 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   AUD-DST for 2024.03.21 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.04.07 03:00  AUD spr: first 7 Sunday  of April: 4
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Th., 2024.03.21 00:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.03.20 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 172799 sec or 47 h, close time: Fr., 2024.03.22 23:59
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -3 h = -10800 sec.
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Th. 2024.03.21 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.03.17 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.03.22 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       172799 s  48.00 h
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.11.03 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.03.31 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:11:18.900    2024.03.21 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:11:19.156    EURUSD : real ticks begin from 2011.12.19 00:00:00


2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.03.25 02:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.11.03 03:00  USD aut: first 3 Sunday  of November: 11
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   DST_EUR for 2024.03.25 02:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.03.31 03:00  EUR spr: last 31 Sunday  of March: 3
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   AUD-DST for 2024.03.25 02:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.04.07 03:00  AUD spr: first 7 Sunday  of April: 4
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Mo., 2024.03.25 02:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.03.24 23:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 424799 sec or 117 h, close time: Fr., 2024.03.29 23:59
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -3 h = -10800 sec.
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Mo. 2024.03.25 02:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.03.24 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.03.29 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       424799 s  118.00 h
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Summer & EU=Winter
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.11.03 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.03.31 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:25.502    2024.04.01 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:25.700    EURUSD : real ticks begin from 2011.12.19 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   DST_EUR for 2024.04.01 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.10.27 03:00  EUR aut: last 27 Sunday  of October: 10
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Setting broker time offset at: Mo., 2024.04.01 00:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.03.31 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Summer
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 431998 sec or 119 h, close time: Fr., 2024.04.05 23:59
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01  
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -3 h = -10800 sec.
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   TimeCurrent:                   Mo. 2024.04.01 00:00:01
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.03.31 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.04.05 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Time left 'till weekend:       431998 s  120.00 h
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Time area:                     US=Summer & EU=Summer
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.11.03 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.10.27 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:12:29.570    2024.04.01 00:00:01   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.04.07 03:00:00


2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   USD-DST for 2024.04.11 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.11.03 03:00  USD aut: first 3 Sunday  of November: 11
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   DST_EUR for 2024.04.11 00:00 DST: -3600  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.10.27 03:00  EUR aut: last 27 Sunday  of October: 10
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   AUD-DST for 2024.04.11 00:00 DST:     0  nxtSwitch: Su. 2024.10.06 03:00  AUD aut: first 6 Sunday  of October: 10
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Setting broker time offset at: Th., 2024.04.11 00:00 for MetaQuotes Software Corp.
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Offest (time+diff=GMT): OffsetBroker.actOffset: -10800   sec => GMT: 2024.04.10 21:00  time area: US=Summer & EU=Summer
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   get the seconds until FX closes (NY 17:00) with SecTillClose(TimeCurrent()): 172799 sec or 47 h, close time: Fr., 2024.04.12 23:59
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00  
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Offset of MetaQuotes Software Corp.: -3 h = -10800 sec.
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   TimeCurrent:                   Th. 2024.04.11 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   First bar of this week:        Su. 2024.04.07 00:00:00
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Last second of this week:      Fr. 2024.04.12 23:59:59
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Time left 'till weekend:       172799 s  48.00 h
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Time area:                     US=Summer & EU=Summer
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch US:            Su. 2024.11.03 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch EU:            Su. 2024.10.27 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:13:09.913    2024.04.11 00:00:00   Next DST switch AU:            Su. 2024.10.06 03:00:00
2024.04.29 07:13:10.043    EURUSD : real ticks begin from 2011.12.19 00:00:00

I can't see any error.


     
    Bretzay #:
    It seems to be working on Saturday, Sunday and Monday as well now, even on my side so that's perfect.

    I still have an incomprehension, that could be on my side, but if you can enlighten me after reading your guides multiple times without understanding, that would be awesome.

    As said, I'm using FTMO, and they switched their DST on NY date (10 March) this year, but when the bot check for DST, instead of moving from +2 to +3 like it would normally do, it did move the GMT from +2 to +4, I'm still really not sure of why it does that. It's not really impactful for now as we're in April/May, but I'd like to understand what happens there.

    Taking into consideration that when comes the European DST, it comes back to a more normal number, which is DST +3 (so going from +2 to +3, which is a normal DST switch),
    I hope it was understandable. It's quite messy in my head right now, so I tried to make it clear

    And as said in my first message, which was telling that I think it's a bug in the code, when I compared a trading hour with trading view putting my trading view time zone to UTC+0, it was off of 1 hour, so I guess that's a coding problem as well. It occurs from 11th of March to 30th of March I think, around that. For the whole NYSumEUWin

    Try this lib on yoor broker to check if it is a broker problem. https://www.mql5.com/en/code/48291

     
    amrali #:

    Try this lib on yoor broker to check if it is a broker problem. https://www.mql5.com/en/code/48291

    Indeed it looks like that's a broker problem, I'm not sure of where I could check to try solving that issue, that's not going to interfere a lot with my bot, but that's still quite a problem, thanks for the help on that!
     
    Bretzay #:
    Indeed it looks like that's a broker problem, I'm not sure of where I could check to try solving that issue, that's not going to interfere a lot with my bot, but that's still quite a problem, thanks for the help on that!

    See here: https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/1111/page3519#comment_53211917

    Ошибки, баги, вопросы
    Ошибки, баги, вопросы
    • 2024.04.21
    • Nikolai Semko
    • www.mql5.com
    Общее обсуждение: Ошибки, баги, вопросы
     
    Carl Schreiber #:

    See here: https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/1111/page3519#comment_53211917

    I really don't think it's the right way of going with it, but I've made a little change to the library to adapt the offset for when the broker decides to switch with NY DST when they use London times, from my understanding, it happens only in March so I did not try to do anything for October (the other dst switch I think).

    bool setBokerOffset(bool winToSumDSTBreak = false, const bool fromInit = true)
{
// Bunch of your code right there
            if(DST_USD!=0 && DST_EUR==0)                          // US:summer EU:winter
               {
                if(winToSumDSTBreak) {OffsetBroker.actOffset = OffsetBroker.USsumEUsum = hDiff*3600 + 3600;}
                else {OffsetBroker.actOffset = OffsetBroker.USsumEUwin = hDiff*3600;}
                OffsetBroker.actSecFX  = sClFX; // lat second of FX-week == Close at: tCl=SoW(TimeCurrent()) + OffsetBroker.actSecFX), time left: tCl - TimeCurrent()= SoW(tB);
                OffsetBroker.set       = true;
               }
// #ifdef part for debug right after (so you can see more easily) It's around line 340 to 350 of your library.
}

    By doing that, when I put the library on my expert advisor, and I know that the broker has that issue we've spoken about, I can just add this in the inputs of my EA : 

    input bool brokerWinToSumProblem = false;       // If your broker has a DST problem in March

    And then in the init function I just need to change "isTimeSet" :

    bool isTimeSet = setBokerOffset( brokerWinToSumProblem  );


    Tell me what you think about it, it's really barbarian way of doing it, but it seems to be working so I won't complain :)

    Files:
    DealingWithTime.mqh  64 kb
     
    Bretzay #:
    I really don't think it's the right way of going with it, but I've made a little change to the library to adapt the offset for when the broker decides to switch with NY DST when they use London times, from my understanding, it happens only in March so I did not try to do anything for October (the other dst switch I think).

    By doing that, when I put the library on my expert advisor, and I know that the broker has that issue we've spoken about, I can just add this in the inputs of my EA : 

    input bool brokerWinToSumProblem = false;       // If your broker has a DST problem in March

    And then in the init function I just need to change "isTimeSet" :

    bool isTimeSet = setBokerOffset( brokerWinToSumProblem  );


    Tell me what you think about it, it's really barbarian way of doing it, but it seems to be working so I won't complain :)

    I'll program tomorrow a solution for such sluggard broker.

    3MACross EA
    3MACross EA
    • www.mql5.com
    An Expert Advisor based on indicators "MA Cross 3MACross Alert WarnSig" (https://www.mql5.com/en/code/19519) and "Price Channel" (https://www.mql5.com/en/code/44)
     
    Carl Schreiber #:

    I'll program tomorrow a solution for such sluggard broker.

    Hi @Carl Schreiber

    There used to be methods to find First Bar and Last Bar of the day, do they still exist somewhere in your lib(s)? If true please share the link.

    I remembered one of your post stating that they no longer works with updated Mql5 version, but not sure about it.

    123456
    New comment
    Reason: